[thedarklord]

I think the dubs can only be judged from show to show. I hate the Naruto dub but I like the InuYasha dub. Of course the bad thing is the American-ized dubs like Naruto where they add annoying catch phrases like "believe it!" To me it also depends on the voices attached to the characters. Using the same example, Naruto's character has an extremely annoying voice in the dub but has a fitting Japanese voice. So my short answer is "it depends."