View Single Post
(#48 (permalink))
Old
ThirdSight's Avatar
ThirdSight (Offline)
Bane of Stupidity
 
Posts: 467
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: California
Send a message via AIM to ThirdSight
10-09-2008, 03:04 PM

After reading your piece, I feel, as I do with everyone's work that I read, that it's only right to give you some honest feedback to further your creative endeavors. The following is my attempt at such feedback; although it's a little harsh, there's nothing worse than someone who will sugarcoat what they say.

Anyhoo,

You're off to horribly great start, meaning that your idea is interesting enough to hold a reader, yet the execution is sub-par. The story starts off in the middle of action, which is a technique used by the best of authors and one that should be practiced (you do this well), however, even after this initial introduction, I still don't know anything about the main character. Why does she feel the way she does? Why is she letting this get the better of her? What's her personality like that'd make her lash out in such a way. All I can tell from this piece is that she's someone who's been bullied a bit too much for her age (something else I'm unaware of), and is looking for someone or something to attach to.

Sadly, it's regrettable that this only made your story more cliche. The conflict is there and plain to see, but it's one that has been beaten to death with a literary stick. The idea of a website where those that have been "abused" gather is quite original, and you have something good going for you with that idea. However, your character's reactions, thought patterns, speech patterns, and nearly everything else about them is so predictable that it takes away the fun and excitement of the unexpected. While the plot of the story remains fantastical, the reader will see what's coming from a mile away.

I may be wrong (being that there's not much revealed about his character), but I fear that Mr. Nobody is a Mary Sue character, or a character that can do whatever he/she/it wants because it wills it. While very creepy already to have someone find your main character on his own, knowing every little bit about her seems far too omnipotent and makes him rather flat (how many times have we seen this in anime/manga/TV/movies/etc.). However, as I said earlier, I can't say for certain if this is true or not, but I would look into his character more in depth to make sure you're not creating a Mary Sue, otherwise, to be blunt, no one will read this piece.

As I've mentioned, the greatest thing you have going for you in this short introductory chapter is your idea. Original to say the least, and could turn provocative should you look closer into the idea and develop it more. Work on developing your characters more: write down their personality, habits, hobbies, thought processes, etc. on a separate piece of paper; in short, write a short story about the character. That should give that third dimension to your characters, and you'll find it's a great deal easier to write when you don't have to worry about how you characters will act in certain situations.

All in all, a diamond in the rough I'd say.



Once again, sorry for being a bit harsh, blunt, and honest, but I'd be cheating you if I was anything otherwise.


-M@

How in the world do people reach 1,000+ posts?


Skadoosh.
Reply With Quote