[Hatredcopter]

Irregardless of who attempted to hit who, the fact that in the vastness of the ocean, this Batmobile of a boat got struck by a huge, slow-moving whaling vessel shows either the complete incompetence of the person piloting the Ady Gil, or that the person piloting the Ady Gil purposely put his boat in harm's way. It would be ridiculous to try and argue that the Ady Gil could not have outmaneuvered the whaling vessel, so long as the person piloting the boat actually knew how to pilot it.

Also, I'm sure the Sea Shepherds took out a nice fat insurance policy on their new boat before launching it on any operations.