JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   General Discussion (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/)
-   -   Bruce Lee (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/14751-bruce-lee.html)

pumpum 04-19-2008 07:06 AM

Bruce Lee
 
Do you think that the conspiracy theories are tru and he was murdered for giving martial arts secrets away to the americans ??

Alastor 04-19-2008 07:31 AM

The guy had a head-ache. His friend game him an aspirin. Unfortunatel, there was a substance/chemical/whatever inside that pill that his body was allergic to, which is brains didn't like, so they sort of killed him. Huh. Imagine that. The legendary Bruce Lee, the man of the one-inch punch, the kick that feels like a juggernaut rnning you over, and the one-arm, two-finger push-ups... the one and only... killed by an aspirin.

pumpum 04-19-2008 07:33 AM

man i never ever believed the one inch punch for a second !

Alastor 04-19-2008 07:36 AM

The one-inch-punch is true, as seen by filming. Bruce Lee did have some unnatural strength, really. I know how he does it, theoretically, and it sounds highly plausible, considering the other things he can do (keep punching a punching bag. He punchesit up and up and up until he's almost punching up and he's still punching it to hold it up.) and his push/side kicks are sick. XD

ivi0nk3y 04-19-2008 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 465359)
I dont know about the one inch punch. Most the vids on it are bullshit, but was Bruce Lee bullshit? Maybe he could do it, few others can. But the general mechanics of the body make it seem unlikely.

A punch is not just powerful if it is fast, but it depends what weight you put behind it. A punch starts at the rear leg, gathers power in the hips, then the shoulders, and then transfers down the arm and into the enemy. But the movement required to recruit this power is more than one inch. So what Bruce claims is he has found a way to recruit the power of the entire body after moving his fist only one inch in distance. From the way his feet moved in the vid I saw, it seemed MAYBE he had, but I still fail to understand exactley how you could do it myself, even being semi professional Muay Thai boxer, I still am trying to understand...

Huh, the way you've described it, that is like a boxing punch not the way they are taught in Kung Fu. I'm trained to focus my energy in my arms when I punch so EVENTUALLY I can have the maximum strength available in the minimum distance. My Sifu can do it and make it look effortless. He did it semi hard to me once because I was punching wrong and it seemed like my intestines fell out my ass.
So yes, I believe it is possible.

As for 2 finger push ups, that isn't THAT amazing to me anymore, especially since I am currently training Eagle Claw pushups which require 2 fingers and a thumb. Of course my Sifu can use just his thumbs >.>

Jaydelart 04-19-2008 05:25 PM

He'd been challenged numerous times throughout his career by random martial artist looking to gain some reputation by beating him. He'd never lost once, and there were almost always witnessess to validate these events.

I'm not in the mood to debate whether or not his methods (or teachings) were bullshit, but whatever he was doing, he must've been doing it right.

As for the conspiracies. I can't say I believe or don't believe them; I simply don't know.

It is possible that someone wanted him dead - I wouldn't have been the first time. And it is also possible that he died by accident.

Whatever the case, what's done is done. The rest are side-details; information after the fact.

Hyakushi 04-20-2008 04:36 AM

I don't believe any conspiracy theories really thats just as bad as believing what you hear on the streets <.< but there were alot of bad blood between martial artist during that time speacialy racial issues. So it could be possible.

pumpum 04-22-2008 10:00 AM

thats an interesting point - i would have also thought mind power came into it - sort of like some extra chi power or something ?

ivi0nk3y 04-22-2008 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 468831)
I am going to put something in the air. From what I have seen, all one inch punch practitioners today are bullshit. They are not doing what Bruce was. When you look at things, like Bruce could thrust a finger through a tin soft drink can (not the soft alluminium we use to make todays soft drink cans), he could leave indentations with his fingers in pine wood. His speed would allow him to snatch a dime from a mans hand and leave a penny before the man could close his hand. With this given, I am thinking along the lines that Bruce could do the one inch punch, because he was so fit and strong, and basically a physical machine. Technique was important, but I am doubting that technique alone can do this. I think technique is 5% of the one inch punch, and physical quality is 95%.

Exactly. Its not like i'll just be able to do it by following the technique my Sifu does. I do know however that if anyone can do it then a long standing practitioner of Kung Fu could.
I can tell you this though, from doing what I do my arms feel much faster and lighter so I can sort of see how Bruce Lee did it.

Sutiiven 04-23-2008 10:11 AM

Well i think he must have had all his time into his training to get as good as he did.

But the least i can remember is that the guy who taught him was a very popular guy and the guy who taught bruce, has a famous son that teaches in his place and writes about bruce getting trained by his father in a kung fu book instruction book .

Hiroki 04-23-2008 10:50 AM

He was the greatest of all R.I.P Lee Jun-Fan

You will be forever in our warrior's soul.


ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sutiiven (Post 469789)
Well i think he must have had all his time into his training to get as good as he did.

He trained two hours a day. 1 hour for Cardio exercises and 1 hour for weight/strength training.

Sutiiven 04-23-2008 11:02 AM

wow that is all well he must have done a ton of reps then .

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sutiiven (Post 469802)
wow that is all well he must have done a ton of reps then .

Well of course he already had his Kung Fu base so he just needed to maintain it :)

Jaydelart 04-23-2008 07:03 PM

Quote:

As for 2 finger push ups, that isn't THAT amazing to me anymore, especially since I am currently training Eagle Claw pushups which require 2 fingers and a thumb. Of course my Sifu can use just his thumbs >.>
Take note of the muscles located at the base of the thumb and compare it to that of the bases of the first 2 fingers.
That thumb provides a significant amount of support in terms of finger push-ups. Take it away, and you're playing on an entirely new level of balance, strength, and endurance.

Also, keep in mind the change in the center-of-gravity. The longer the fingers, the higher the center-of-gravity -- and the more difficult it is to retain balance.

A man may be able to do Eagle Claw push-ups, but that doesn't necessarily mean he can do 2-Finger push-ups.

I'm not trying to degrade you. I'm simply pointing out the difference.

You're a martial artist. It's not surprising that you'd be less "AMAZED", because you should be more capable of understanding it for what it is.

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 470049)
That is bullshit, Ivon, who told you that? Bruce Lee would stay up late into the night practicing on his wooden dummy. 2 hours a day will turn over little talent, esp. if you spend it only on cardio and weights, he was supposed to be a fighter???

Your understanding of what I said is bullshit Tenchu.
If you re-read, I said that it was to maintain the base he already had. I didn't say he got to where he was by training two hours a day.

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaydelart (Post 470510)
Take note of the muscles located at the base of the thumb and compare it to that of the bases of the first 2 fingers.
That thumb provides a significant amount of support in terms of finger push-ups. Take it away, and you're playing on an entirely new level of balance, strength, and endurance.

Also, keep in mind the change in the center-of-gravity. The longer the fingers, the higher the center-of-gravity -- and the more difficult it is to retain balance.

A man may be able to do Eagle Claw push-ups, but that doesn't necessarily mean he can do 2-Finger push-ups.

I'm not trying to degrade you. I'm simply pointing out the difference.

You're a martial artist. It's not surprising that you'd be less "AMAZED", because you should be more capable of understanding it for what it is.

I know the fingers have less potential in them on their own.
Also, I never said because someone did Eagle Claw pushups, they could do 2-finger ones as well. My point was to say that I can do them right now and will be able to do 2 finger pushups soon as well, without my thumbs :rolleyes: So as far as pushups go, 2-finger ones aren't that amazing to me, since I was replying to someone who quoted these pushups as being a reason why Bruce Lee was amazing.

Jaydelart 04-23-2008 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 470606)
Also, I never said because someone did Eagle Claw pushups, they could do 2-finger ones as well.

I wasn't saying you said that. Don't misunderstand me. I was simply pointing out the difference.

What I was trying to say: You are less AMAZED by it maybe because you are also a martial artist; A practitioner of physical expression. A professional [anything] may seem more amazing to a mere spectator than to a fellow professional.

Understand what I'm trying to say?

If not, I'm sorry. And I'll just leave it at that.

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 08:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaydelart (Post 470673)
I wasn't saying you said that. Don't misunderstand me. I was simply pointing out the difference.

What I was trying to say: You are less AMAZED by it maybe because you are also a martial artist; A practitioner of physical expression. A professional [anything] may seem more amazing to a mere spectator than to a fellow professional.

Understand what I'm trying to say?

If not, I'm sorry. And I'll just leave it at that.

Lol I understand, that's no problem. That was however my point but also the fact that anyone can do it with a little will power :D

yuujirou 04-23-2008 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 470674)
Lol I understand, that's no problem. That was however my point but also the fact that anyone can do it with a little will power :D

x]
more than just a "little'' power, lolz

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 08:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yuujirou (Post 470690)
x]
more than just a "little'' power, lolz

You are only as weak as you make yourself think you are ;)

yuujirou 04-23-2008 08:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 470698)
You are only as weak as you make yourself think you are ;)

martial arts are half mental, half physical >.>''

ivi0nk3y 04-23-2008 10:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yuujirou (Post 470737)
martial arts are half mental, half physical >.>''

That really depends. Its like when i'm training and am at my limit, my mental takes over. Like to keep doing a certain pushup/take a punch to the stomach/kick to the shoulder, I have to go into my "zone" where I accept the pain as nothing significant.
Till then however, i'm almost 100% physical.

tokyoscgirl21 04-24-2008 01:31 AM

well theres a rumor going round that the chinese mafia loaded the gun that killed Brandon Lee.

Ronin4hire 04-24-2008 02:36 AM

Bruce Lee is probably my all time favourite Martial Artist. The Jeet Kune Do philosophy is very inspiring in my opinion. Not just in Martial Arts but spiritually speaking also.

Ronin4hire 04-27-2008 05:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 472972)



But I have never been a fan of those people who say like "True masters do not compete in tournaments" and so on. I reckon people who say this are just afraid of humility. Bruce would have known if he got into a kick boxing ring he would have gotten smacked in the head a thousand times, even if he won every fight, which some do, he still would have taken a few beatings to win it. The best and most refined skills are the ones that are put to the test and mastered in a proper fight. I know I trust my teachers because they have paid for their mistakes with blood and tears, as will I soon. Someone saying this is a bad thing is either afraid of being hit, for whatever reason, or knows their skills are inferior and cant bear the shame of looseing.

Seriously... not everybody cares about the fighting.

For example my friend's Wushu teacher is amazing. She trained with Jet Li as a kid and is respected as a master by many top wushu practitioners throughout China. Her reputation as a master comes not from beating up people in a ring but via her speed, athleticism, skill and grace as a martial artist which she displays. Even at 50+ years old!

yukiNnight 04-27-2008 05:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 465363)
Huh, the way you've described it, that is like a boxing punch not the way they are taught in Kung Fu. I'm trained to focus my energy in my arms when I punch so EVENTUALLY I can have the maximum strength available in the minimum distance. My Sifu can do it and make it look effortless. He did it semi hard to me once because I was punching wrong and it seemed like my intestines fell out my ass.
So yes, I believe it is possible.

As for 2 finger push ups, that isn't THAT amazing to me anymore, especially since I am currently training Eagle Claw pushups which require 2 fingers and a thumb. Of course my Sifu can use just his thumbs >.>

wow u know some chinese

yuujirou 04-27-2008 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 472972)
I would say that it is 99% mental, 1% physical. However, that 1% physical takes up 99% of your training, and only a small part of training is dedicated to sitting around thinking about it.

At the end of the day it does not matter what skills you have collected, it is power of will, determination and resolve that is going to keep you on your feet, but only if this 1% of physically has consumed your every day beforehand, and you are ultimately trained. It is not a simple thing.

Anyway, Kung Fu means 'martial technique that takes time to master' or something similar. It is a lifetime devotion. I doubt Bruce Lee trained only 2 hours a day. I do at least 6 hours a day of physical training, and he is still better looking than me. Plus, you can not learn Kung Fu and then say "I know it now, all I have to do is keep my physique up and I will be a master for forever" that is stupid. You have to continue to practice your skills all day every day to keep getting better. And I was told this is what he did do, and he trained late into the night and early every morning.

But I have never been a fan of those people who say like "True masters do not compete in tournaments" and so on. I reckon people who say this are just afraid of humility. Bruce would have known if he got into a kick boxing ring he would have gotten smacked in the head a thousand times, even if he won every fight, which some do, he still would have taken a few beatings to win it. The best and most refined skills are the ones that are put to the test and mastered in a proper fight. I know I trust my teachers because they have paid for their mistakes with blood and tears, as will I soon. Someone saying this is a bad thing is either afraid of being hit, for whatever reason, or knows their skills are inferior and cant bear the shame of looseing.

kung fu ish hard work, or a skill obtained through hard work >.>'''

about the fighting thingg~~~
there are people who have achieved such a personal level of skill that they fear to fight, for both the safety of themselves and others. >.>'

personally, this one ish too scared to fight people ^_^
for the same reason stated above.
i'd much rather just run away than to risk hurting myself or the opponent~
(then again, there are those fights that you can't just run from...but then again, you don't have to "enjoy" such fights)

and meh~ martial arts isn't just for fighting. >.>'''
the system is based on the fighting arts, but there are usually philosophies involved with the art...usually peaceful ones x]

ivi0nk3y 04-27-2008 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 472972)
I would say that it is 99% mental, 1% physical. However, that 1% physical takes up 99% of your training, and only a small part of training is dedicated to sitting around thinking about it.

At the end of the day it does not matter what skills you have collected, it is power of will, determination and resolve that is going to keep you on your feet, but only if this 1% of physically has consumed your every day beforehand, and you are ultimately trained. It is not a simple thing.

Anyway, Kung Fu means 'martial technique that takes time to master' or something similar. It is a lifetime devotion. I doubt Bruce Lee trained only 2 hours a day. I do at least 6 hours a day of physical training, and he is still better looking than me. Plus, you can not learn Kung Fu and then say "I know it now, all I have to do is keep my physique up and I will be a master for forever" that is stupid. You have to continue to practice your skills all day every day to keep getting better. And I was told this is what he did do, and he trained late into the night and early every morning.

But I have never been a fan of those people who say like "True masters do not compete in tournaments" and so on. I reckon people who say this are just afraid of humility. Bruce would have known if he got into a kick boxing ring he would have gotten smacked in the head a thousand times, even if he won every fight, which some do, he still would have taken a few beatings to win it. The best and most refined skills are the ones that are put to the test and mastered in a proper fight. I know I trust my teachers because they have paid for their mistakes with blood and tears, as will I soon. Someone saying this is a bad thing is either afraid of being hit, for whatever reason, or knows their skills are inferior and cant bear the shame of looseing.

To answer your first statement about it being 99% mental. Yes initially, it is more mental when you think about it that way. The same rules apply to the gym or losing weight or any other activity which needs will power and determination to succeed. It doesn't apply solely to Kung Fu.
However, I don't need to be so determined anymore. It comes naturally.
So much so that if I even miss a class or haven't worked hard enough, I feel like crap cos I feel like i'm losing out big time.
Anyway, i'm talking about will power and determination in the actual training that you do. The technical side of it is more physical for me now since that is what i'm training. In "training" I can only use my mental once my physical peak is reached because that is when the mental most comes into play.

As for Bruce Lees training regime, that is what I have learned from his own biography as I said. If you disagree, then you'd have to give me another source. Anyway, I don't agree with training 6 hours a day. That is absolutely silly. Your body won't even have time to recover from your last training.
I'm talking about NEW training and pushing yourself every session, not doing the same amount of exercises that you're used to. If you're pushing yourself, there is no need to train 6 hours a day. Unless you're doing some hard-type qi-gong exercises which take an hour each when performed properly.. which even then would burn you out so hard you wouldn't be able to move.

Quote:

Originally Posted by yukiNnight (Post 473784)
wow u know some chinese

Only some :)

Alastor 04-27-2008 03:28 PM

Time has little matter. It's how effective your training is.

Bruce's philosophy when it came to fighting was basically to discard anything that was useless in martial arts and had the practitioner absorb nothing bt the useful parts. So there was no real fighting style, just effective fighting. And when possessing that skill, you go on about the rest of your life until the need to kick ass arises. Then you proceed to kick ass.

Fighting in a ring, I've noticed, is so different because it does away with much of the mentality. In a REAL fight, there is no time for mental preparations. No time to psyche yourself up; no time to warm yourself up. That initial surprse element is a huge factor, and in any daily life situation, it's often also a determining factor.

ivi0nk3y 04-27-2008 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 474019)
I dont have a life, you guys have jobs. I just wanne fight. So yeah, keep up with your part time training and give it 100% while you are there and you will be a champion amongst civis! Bruce, though, claimed not to be an innocent, not a civi, and he is another story.

I think you mis-understand me and my "part-time" training. I train every day, whether that be direct Kung Fu or just going to the gym when there are no sessions. I also have a job and study and do a lot of other things at the same time but I do take training quite seriously. Don't assume to place me in a stereotype which you are familiar with.
I don't want to be like Bruce Lee but he is one of the inspirations for me acquiring strength. I wish he was still around so I could have seen more of his talents.

Alastor 04-27-2008 03:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 474056)
I think you mis-understand me and my "part-time" training. I train every day, whether that be direct Kung Fu or just going to the gym when there are no sessions. I also have a job and study and do a lot of other things at the same time but I do take training quite seriously. Don't assume to place me in a stereotype which you are familiar with.
I don't want to be like Bruce Lee but he is one of the inspirations for me acquiring strength. I wish he was still around so I could have seen more of his talents.

He's Chinese, I don't think he has that many other talents.

ivi0nk3y 04-27-2008 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastor (Post 474068)
He's Chinese, I don't think he has that many other talents.

If I go along with that stereotype, there are so many other things the Chinese are good at :rolleyes:

Alastor 04-27-2008 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ivi0nk3y (Post 474074)
If I go along with that stereotype, there are so many other things the Chinese are good at :rolleyes:

I hope you know what I meant by "talent" ;)

But yeah, it's common consensus that it doesn't matter how good you are at something because there will always be a Chinese who is better than you at it.

ivi0nk3y 04-27-2008 06:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastor (Post 474076)
I hope you know what I meant by "talent" ;)

But yeah, it's common consensus that it doesn't matter how good you are at something because there will always be a Chinese who is better than you at it.

Hmm well, I personally don't take those stereotypes too seriously, especially of certain "talents". :)

Ronin4hire 04-28-2008 04:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 474019)
Many people have reputation in one sense or another. I would not consider this a Warriors rep. I dont call a world class Wushu artist a Warrior, they dont even train to fight anymore, just to look good.

I was talking specifically about tearing mens guts out with your fists. Nothing else. Something Bruce Lee claimed was baseless to practice in a ring. I dont agree. Tournament fighting is the next step on sparring. If Bruce disliked either of these things then he did not train realistically.


Well Bruce always sparred. He just didn't fight in the ring that much. The idea being that fighting in the ring makes you restricted to the rules of the particular sport you are competing in (Muay Thai, Boxing, Wrestling etc...).

Alastor 04-28-2008 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
Is this speaking from experience here? Or is this the philosophy your Karate teacher told you as an excuse for being lazy? Actually, my old Kung Fu teacher DID tell me this. He said there was little point in full time training because you can only obsorb so much information at once! What an idiot, I dont believe people can actually believe that a guy who practices 3 times a week stands a chance against a full time practitioner... Now, there is such thing as effective training, and one day of useless training is not as good as one hour of good training, however, one day of good training is better than one hour of good training. Your body can recover, get stronger, and there are many types of good exersizes that can be done to consume your day without wrecking your body. The key you are looking for is effective training + time. Time matters, hence the very meaning of Kung Fu.



Your know-it-all attitude failed now, I'm afraid. I have no karate teacher. Never had, either. I think Karate, as a fighting art, is stupid. It is true you can only absorb so much information at once, although this has nothing to do with honing your skills. You already know them making them better isn't absorbing more information, it's letting the knowledge grow within you. And yes, if you look at your body and muscles, you can't practise non-stop. You need your eight hours of sleep, you need t let your body rest during and after eating, you need to let those muscles rebuild, etc. This is why you sleep Tenchu, and have time to hang around JapanForum, play videogames, drink beer and eat pizza. I never said time doesn't matter, but it doesn't matter as much a being effective. Once you're effectiv, time is only how much willpower you have to keep on going, and how long before you feel you've had enough training. And these are all factor determined by your focus and determination, not time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
Firstly, as Musashi said, a Warrior must learn to turn his attitude in an instant so he is constantly ready. I need about 1 second for mental prep, and I am about as angry as a burning bull. Warm ups are okay, but only old men truly need them. Most skills can be done well without warm ups, this is not a big thing. Catching a man off gaurd is good. I will give you that. God forbid an assassin determines the best time to hit me is at 2100 at night, when I am bloated with pizza and drunk from beer! Yes, surprise is good. My teacher, Musashi, however, was never off gaurd. He would even not bathe for fear of been caught naked and exposed by an enemy. I think though he did bathe sometime, in secluded rivers and streams in the wilderness, I doubt he NEVER did, but, still, you see how men can train to be constantly ready. Musashi, also, was a duel fighter. Like a tournament, where you are given time to warm up and psyche up, but there are no rules in the actual fight, he killed ALL his opponents.



I see in competitions all the time where these guys sit around for X amount of time warming up in the locker rooms, and then they get to stand in front of their opponent and mentally preare to fight THAT individual before the fight begins. Very different from eating a sundae wearing jeans and a shirt, and then suddeny realizing you have to fight this guy who wants to stab you to death. Usually, half the fight is won before the fight.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
Well, I was not inuslting you. I dunno, I just assume most you guys do just small 3 nights a week training or something, coz you all students or got jobs.



You need to stop assuming so much, then.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
This is a common thought, so I am going to give you the exception that you have pretty much just quoted what you have heard, and not thought it through in great detail. Do you really believe this? Really?



Yes, being in a ring with rules does bloody restrict you, period. You don't have to be a rocket scientist to understand that a real fight is different from a competitive sports fight.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
I train Muay Thai mostly, but just because I am bound by rules do you think on the street I dont know how to kick the balls, throat, or gouge the eyes? I think every serious fighter might train with rules, but only a fool is eternally bound by them.



I think a Ninjutsu or Judo practitioner know plenty more grappling, throwing and locking techniques/principles than you do. Not counting the techniques that require your opponent wearing a Gi. So, just a question. When you practice, how often do you practice against a live target? After all, pads and wooden dolls don't fight back.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
So, I would love to train only for real fighting, and then duel like Musashi did. But where the fuck will I get money? Tournament fighting is a legitamite profession, one that will allow me to continue to train martial skills full time, as was the Army. And in the case of Muay Thai, the only reason there are rules is because all the fighters kept dieing or being permanently injured, so rules came into play to help allow the sport to flourish, and people not to die so much. The old way was to get into a ring and just fight to the death, no breaks, no ref, last man standing.



Funny, what happens when you're the one who ends up dead? The very concept of me willingly having a job where there is a 50-50 chance of me dying is just aburd. I'm expecting to live another 60 years, I wouldn't want to miss out 50 of those.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)
The fact remains, the best fighter will be the one who trains the most. The one who trains the most is the one who has the time and money to do it, the one who has the time and money to do it is the one who makes money from doing it. And every fuckin Muay Thai fighter or BJJ dude or MMA fighter or whatever, they know how to fight dirty, they are not stupid.

So, whoever told you what you said is plain dumb, k.

No. Whoever has the greatest skills is the best fighter. If AAA trains 10 hours a week and BBB trains 20 hours a week, but AAA's training is more efective and AAA's 10 hours serves AAA better than BBB's 20 hours serves BBB. Thus, AAA will beat BBB.


Tenchu, from what I've gathered, you're a serious Muay Thai practitioner. You want to fight, and you also think that tournament fighting is a good way to earn money, to support you so you can keep on fighting. The thing is, why are you practising Muay Thai? Why don't you just practice fighting, period? I know Muay Thai is very close to that, but why restrict yourself? Actively practicing everything makes everything easier. Sure you can gouge eyes, but can you swiftly and with accuracy do it? What about pressure points, grappling, ground fighting, etc.?

yuujirou 04-28-2008 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastor (Post 475113)
[/color]


Tenchu, from what I've gathered, you're a serious Muay Thai practitioner. You want to fight, and you also think that tournament fighting is a good way to earn money, to support you so you can keep on fighting. The thing is, why are you practising Muay Thai? Why don't you just practice fighting, period? I know Muay Thai is very close to that, but why restrict yourself? Actively practicing everything makes everything easier. Sure you can gouge eyes, but can you swiftly and with accuracy do it? What about pressure points, grappling, ground fighting, etc.?

there are purists...
then there are mma >.>'''

this one ish purist though x]
preferring to stick to just shaolin ^_^

Alastor 04-28-2008 04:32 PM

Nah, I think I can see your point. So any disagreements between us is basically only a matter of opinion, nothing else, I don't think we need to continue on that anymore. It's just that in the times when you're not the warrior in the field, you're human just like us. The rules of politeness still applies, and assuming you're better than anyone without any basis is ... well... usually not a good thing.

With that said, I think we should get back on topic. Bruce Lee.

I think his philosophy (Jeet Kune Do) is pretty spot-on. But he was a fairly cocky person himself - if you believe the stories told by people who have interacted with him. I am a strong believer of being humble, strong and fair.

Tenchu, just to make it clear... can you make yourself angry just like hat? I know I could psyche myself up in no time, but in a tournament fight, it's like, you shake hands before and after the fight (if able), and I can't fathom myself being angry at this person who hasn't done anything to me before. I could see myself, owever, feeling a determination to overcome the opponent.

As for the adaptation, I was smply asking because I wasn't sure. Glad to see you haven't narrowed yourself down to just Muay Thai. Not that I'm discrediting the sport, it's THE best sport to practice if you want to fight like the warriors did in the old das when they were unarmed. I personally wanted to start Muay Thai and went to a few training sessions but the trainer couldn't communicate (or even speak the language), and it all felt rather... lame. Plus my body physique wouldn't allow me to practice Muay Thai (I'm far too skinny, believe me).

Ah, I almost got an urge to start practicing a martial art again... it feels to good to knock some wood (and people). I just need to put on some weight.

Ronin4hire 04-29-2008 01:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 475088)


This is a common thought, so I am going to give you the exception that you have pretty much just quoted what you have heard, and not thought it through in great detail. Do you really believe this? Really?

I train Muay Thai mostly, but just because I am bound by rules do you think on the street I dont know how to kick the balls, throat, or gouge the eyes? I think every serious fighter might train with rules, but only a fool is eternally bound by them.

Believe me, if this were the old days in a country like Japan, I would have submitted myself to a Lord when I was 14 and given my life to fighting in realism for life and death. But this is not those days. I joined the Army but got booted after 9 months. There are few professions a man who wishes the title of Warrior can take. Bruce took one, an actor, showing your skills on TV. Another is the Army, I tried it, but got kicked out for argue with police. Another is a teacher, but I think that is for older men to teach. So I am choosing tournament fighter.

So, I would love to train only for real fighting, and then duel like Musashi did. But where the fuck will I get money? Tournament fighting is a legitamite profession, one that will allow me to continue to train martial skills full time, as was the Army. And in the case of Muay Thai, the only reason there are rules is because all the fighters kept dieing or being permanently injured, so rules came into play to help allow the sport to flourish, and people not to die so much. The old way was to get into a ring and just fight to the death, no breaks, no ref, last man standing.

The fact remains, the best fighter will be the one who trains the most. The one who trains the most is the one who has the time and money to do it, the one who has the time and money to do it is the one who makes money from doing it. And every fuckin Muay Thai fighter or BJJ dude or MMA fighter or whatever, they know how to fight dirty, they are not stupid.

So, whoever told you what you said is plain dumb, k.

Like I said... Bruce sparred realistically so you can rest assured that he trained a lot and trained for realism. Bruce jumping in the Muay Thai, Boxing or Karate ring would be silly because it WOULD restrict HIM. I don't think he despised or looked down on fighters that entered the ring either. In fact one of his favourite fighters was Muhammed Ali and much of his punching techniques come from boxing.

Also Bruce's philosophy on fighting was his legacy rather than his ability. Though Bruce's martial ability was amazing. I don't know why you can't accept that and stop with this "dick measuring" that you're doing at the moment.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:41 PM.

SEO by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6