JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   General Discussion (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/)
-   -   Guns on University campuses, legal? (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/24524-guns-university-campuses-legal.html)

cridgit001 04-16-2009 06:10 PM

Guns on University campuses, legal?
 
So today in my Government class my professor brought to light a bill that is currently going through legislation in Texas. If passed the bill would allow people that have CHLs(Concealed Handgun License) to carry their weapon on campuses legally onto all Texas universities. The purpose of this would be to allow students in a Virgina Tech type situation to defend themselves against any would be killer. One proposition was that the professors would have lists of those that had CHLs in their classroom. Any thoughts?

Note: The process of acquiring a CHL is expensive and thorough with background checks among other things.

Here's the link about CHLs if you want to go in depth. Texas Department of Public Safety - Regulatory Licensing Service Concealed Handgun Licensing

TalnSG 04-16-2009 06:16 PM

That bill has raised a lot of media attention, as it should.
As one who believes in gun ownership, but also in licensing them and responsible ownership, I also work at a university.

I have a problem with this bill, because I do not feel that any weapon belongs in a classroom unless it is as a teaching tool.

But I also feel I should be able to carry it in my vehicle that is parked on campus, if I have a legal permit to transport it.

This bill is very poorly written and needs to be killed, before it gets students and faculty killed by being passed.

MMM 04-16-2009 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cridgit001 (Post 698940)
One proposition was that the professors would have lists of those that had CHLs in their classroom. Any thoughts?

What could possibly be gained by giving the professor the list of who is carrying a gun? That sounds like a dangerous idea and a violation of rights.

Kenpachi11 04-16-2009 06:24 PM

Im not to sure if letting the students have a gun is a great idea but i would understand if an teacher/professor had one so he/she could protect the students.

alanX 04-16-2009 06:34 PM

Don't worry about it. It'll never pass in 1,000,000 years.

MMM 04-16-2009 06:58 PM

This is the same state that eliminated contraception education from its schools textbooks and is now requiring intelligent design and creationism talk in biology textbooks. Don't tell Texas what they can and can't do.

noodle 04-16-2009 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TalnSG (Post 698944)
But I also feel I should be able to carry it in my vehicle that is parked on campus, if I have a legal permit to transport it.

I think if you want to have a gun outside your home, it should always be on you... Leaving it in a vehicle is no way a good idea any day of the week!

kyo_9 04-16-2009 07:55 PM

isn't America the safest country in the world?

Yuusuke 04-16-2009 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyo_9 (Post 698989)
isn't America the safest country in the world?

you can't be serious?

could you please specify what you mean by "safe"

FeyOberon 04-16-2009 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyo_9 (Post 698989)
isn't America the safest country in the world?

Even assuming that to be true (I've never researched the statistics), horrible things like Virginia Tech do happen here.

Texas legislators are attempting to improve that level of safety.

That being said, I agree with MMM -- nothing good can come of providing professors with a list of licensed students.

cridgit001 04-16-2009 09:32 PM

The list thing was something that was mentioned in class. Pretty sure it's not in the bill. Supposedly Mississippi is also considering it. I'd rather have it and not need it than need it and not have it, and being in my car would do no good to me huddled behind a turned over table.

TalnSG 04-20-2009 09:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenpachi11 (Post 698947)
Im not to sure if letting the students have a gun is a great idea but i would understand if an teacher/professor had one so he/she could protect the students.

I can see why some might think this good, but I see two problems with even the teacher/professor carrying a firearm.

1) I was always taught (even in NRA shooting classes) that the main problem with firearms is that they can be taken from you and used on you. Would you really want an attacker to know exactly to go after first to disarm?

2) At least two of my professors in college were certified mentally unstable. I am not exaggerating, one of them warned us the first day of her class. And then were was more than one elderly person with extremely limited vision. Professors are hired for their knowledge on a given subject - sometimes despite other serious limitations.

TalnSG 04-20-2009 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noodle (Post 698968)
I think if you want to have a gun outside your home, it should always be on you... Leaving it in a vehicle is no way a good idea any day of the week!

I work on a college campus where continues to be illegal to have any firearm. If I were allowed to at least lock it in my trunk during office hours (well out of sight), I would have it if I needed it on my drive to and from work.

rison 04-20-2009 10:00 PM

This is quite serious, If the bill gets passed then America has to start dealling with increased crime.There is no way this wont result into something bad.

And the safest country isnt America, its finland or Demark.

Well if the student who carries one is required to have a shooting test before he's qualified then goes on to misfire during an altercation with an attacker and God-forbid hits an innocent.Will he be charged for man-slaughter?

Hobby 04-21-2009 06:41 AM

maybe this is unique in the United States

Hyakushi 04-21-2009 07:08 PM

WTF! giving kids fire arms these days, dang so much has changed. If the bill is passed or not people will keep finding ways to beat the system and break rules with out being caught. Its been going on for ages. This bill will just make it easier for people in general to carry guns, if its for self defense or not. I'm not scared of guns, no one should be scared of guns, if you know how to use them properly then nothing bad will happen. What is scary about kids having guns is they are going through times where all they want to say is "F%&$ you" and are hot headed, if a teacher is giving a student a rough time then the student would be like "Oh well I'm not 18 and there is no death penalty so F$%& it" *Pops off a few rounds in the teachers ars*.
I really hope the bill does not pass, there is already a gun control problem out on the streets so why the hell are we inviting it into schools. Clean up the streets first then maybe the schools might get better.

TalnSG 04-21-2009 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 701240)
.......... What is scary about kids having guns is they are going through times where all they want to say is "F%&$ you" and are hot headed, if a teacher is giving a student a rough time then the student would be like "Oh well I'm not 18 and there is no death penalty so F$%& it" *Pops off a few rounds in the teachers ars*.

That already happens. One of my best friends in college was killed when one of his student just walked in and shot him during his first year teaching - in 1975 in Austin, TX.

It still going to happen. Unfortunately this bill would mean the schools would probably have to remove the metal detectors used to reduce the weapons brought on campus, making it so much easier.

As for the death penalty, it gets adjusted downward when a 16 year old commits a deliberate, premeditated crime like that, so their age is no defense. If they don't have a documented history of mental problems most DAs can prove them competant to stand trial as an adult.

LuckyLuck 04-22-2009 12:55 AM

I'm not a fan of gun "rights" to begin with. So naturally, I do not agree with this bill. It is completely unnecessary for people to bring guns to an educational unit. Adolescents have a tendency to take an inch and turn it into a mile, I can defiantly see the amount of violence in schools increasing if this bill passes, but I have a feeling it won't. It's way to illogical.

cridgit001 04-22-2009 02:06 AM

You realize, this is college right, people with this would be 21+, not quite adolescents.

LuckyLuck 04-22-2009 02:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cridgit001 (Post 701398)
You realize, this is college right, people with this would be 21+, not quite adolescents.

Being twenty one doesn't make anyone a " grown up" Lol. Working a real job, supporting a real family and having major responsibilities determines that. Most college students are yet to have experienced any of that, they're still going through that, " I'm invincible" phase, which makes them adolescents in a nontechnical sense. Please notice how I say "most" that doesn't mean all of them and certaintly isn't directed towards anyone here. I'm only twenty myself.

cridgit001 04-22-2009 04:19 AM

I wanted to clarify the age group, you made it sound like they wanted to give guns to a bunch of 15 year olds.

Hyakushi 04-22-2009 05:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TalnSG (Post 701283)
That already happens. One of my best friends in college was killed when one of his student just walked in and shot him during his first year teaching - in 1975 in Austin, TX.

It still going to happen. Unfortunately this bill would mean the schools would probably have to remove the metal detectors used to reduce the weapons brought on campus, making it so much easier.

As for the death penalty, it gets adjusted downward when a 16 year old commits a deliberate, premeditated crime like that, so their age is no defense. If they don't have a documented history of mental problems most DAs can prove them competant to stand trial as an adult.

Exactly.
Where I went to school not only were the teachers scared of the students they dont care what happens to anyone as long as they are safe. They had metal detectors and still we found a way to get guns into the school (I'm not going to say how) either way the outcome is the same. Age wise does not matter a 40 year old could and almost always acts like they are still going through puburty <_<. Personaly I would prefer women owning and carrying guns with them then men.

Pexster 04-22-2009 05:20 PM

I dunno about that still(About a Women carring a gun instead a man). Humans are unpredicitable.

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pexster (Post 701896)
I dunno about that still(About a Women carring a gun instead a man). Humans are unpredicitable.

Some women are more mature then men, actually most are and they are more indanger of being beatin down or forced to do something they do want (If you get my drift). Men are like children through out there whole lives, most are too proud to admit they have done something wrong and or get angry. Which causes them not to think, so they just shoot.

Pexster 04-29-2009 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706868)
Some women are more mature then men, actually most are and they are more indanger of being beatin down or forced to do something they do want (If you get my drift). Men are like children through out there whole lives, most are too proud to admit they have done something wrong and or get angry. Which causes them not to think, so they just shoot.

How do you know that they are mature than men? I mean, yeah maybe you seen a couple of mature women. But They are still unpredictable, like men. That is why I don't think the law should be passed.

rison 04-29-2009 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706868)
Some women are more mature then men, actually most are and they are more indanger of being beatin down or forced to do something they do want (If you get my drift). Men are like children through out there whole lives, most are too proud to admit they have done something wrong and or get angry. Which causes them not to think, so they just shoot.

I strongly disagree with this.

Pexster 04-29-2009 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rison (Post 706902)
I strongly disagree with this.

Thank you, finally someone understands.

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pexster (Post 706897)
How do you know that they are mature than men? I mean, yeah maybe you seen a couple of mature women. But They are still unpredictable, like men. That is why I don't think the law should be passed.

Crime rates and convict profiles (hahahahahah! I do all this BS paper work hahaha awww sucks though cause I'm new).
I always thought that too but when I started doing APD reports I found that there were more men who commited serious crime such as murder, Identity theft and for women it was mostly just pety crimes like stealing, DWIs, and domestic violence. There is something about women, they are sneakier than men, they plan instead of just loosing there cool.

Anyways yeah I would feel better if my close girlfriends would carry something for protection.

tohruchan7 04-29-2009 05:35 PM

ya dito whats the point in having a gun on campuse?? it will just make it even more crazy. we as humans are unpredictable what if someone had a gun and accidently shoot thier friend on thier foot?? it will just cause more crime.

tohruchan7 04-29-2009 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706907)
Crime rates and convict profiles (hahahahahah! I do all this BS paper work hahaha awww sucks though cause I'm new).
I always thought that too but when I started doing APD reports I found that there were more men who commited serious crime such as murder, Identity theft and for women it was mostly just pety crimes like stealing, DWIs, and domestic violence. There is something about women, they are sneakier than men, they plan instead of just loosing there cool.

Anyways yeah I would feel better if my close girlfriends would carry something for protection.

well thats great for ur girlfriend then but not everyone wants/needs a gun.

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rison (Post 706902)
I strongly disagree with this.

Why is that? I mean its cool having your own theorys but humans are not really as unpredicitable as everyone thinks (Which everyone thinks so you think that and millions others think that, that itself is not unpredicitable). Humans are made and feel the same things <_<, so how unpredicitable can humans in general be? just because we know a few.

tohruchan7 04-29-2009 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706918)
Why is that? I mean its cool having your own theorys but humans are not really as unpredicitable as everyone thinks (Which everyone thinks so you think that and millions others think that, that itself is not unpredicitable). Humans are made and feel the same things <_<, so how unpredicitable can humans in general be? just because we know a few.

ok if we share the same feelings and what not then how come we all have different opions??

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tohruchan7 (Post 706914)
well thats great for ur girlfriend then but not everyone wants/needs a gun.

Well let me ask you is this bill Forcing you in anyway to spend your money on a firearm?. No that is common sense, no point in pointing that out but what I'm stateing is that guns have always found there way into schools. This wll just make it easier and I'm not disagreeing with anyone, I'm just saying what I know and what I think on the subject. I'm not running around shooting rounds after roundsinto the air.

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tohruchan7 (Post 706923)
ok if we share the same feelings and what not then how come we all have different opions??

What different opinion do you have? you aswell as others in this thread say "NO" that is not a different opinion. No one is unique, you will find people who share the same ideas and assperitons.

kei0kusanagi 04-29-2009 05:47 PM

school = where you learn ,supposed to be a safe campus. guns legal on school campus? NO WAY!!! but it doesnt matter with license or nolicense when people get bullied or when the persons had it, someone will bring a gun to school. I dont support people who bring guns to school and kill people but sometimes bullies will never get it until something is done.

Hyakushi 04-29-2009 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kei0kusanagi (Post 706927)
school = where you learn ,supposed to be a safe campus. guns legal on school campus? NO WAY!!! but it doesnt matter with license or nolicense when people get bullied or when the persons had it, someone will bring a gun to school. I dont support people who bring guns to school and kill people but sometimes bullies will never get it until something is done.

People just need to grow up in school and actually learn something instead of causeing unnessisary drama (dont be idiots and be a black kid telling a mexican kid they need to go back to there own country when the both of them need to head back to there own country).
Maybe this thread shouldbe tied in with the thread "School system" or something like that. You think?.

kei0kusanagi 04-29-2009 06:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706938)
People just need to grow up in school and actually learn something instead of causeing unnessisary drama (dont be idiots and be a black kid telling a mexican kid they need to go back to there own country when the both of them need to head back to there own country).
Maybe this thread shouldbe tied in with the thread "School system" or something like that. You think?.

I agree with you there.

tohruchan7 04-29-2009 06:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hyakushi (Post 706938)
People just need to grow up in school and actually learn something instead of causeing unnessisary drama (dont be idiots and be a black kid telling a mexican kid they need to go back to there own country when the both of them need to head back to there own country).
Maybe this thread shouldbe tied in with the thread "School system" or something like that. You think?.

whoa man u just dissed me!! viva la mexico

kei0kusanagi 04-29-2009 06:19 PM

LMAO!!!!!!!!!! he did, but it's just an example, don't take it serious, im a Chink! @_@

tohruchan7 04-29-2009 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kei0kusanagi (Post 706953)
LMAO!!!!!!!!!! he did, but it's just an example, don't take it serious, im a Chink! @_@

ya i know im not i was just sayin incase someone else took it the wrong way.
anyway... i just think skool is ment to learn stuff and thiers no point in bringing a gun.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:14 AM.

SEO by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6