JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   General Discussion (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/)
-   -   Courage of the Fukushima 50. True Heroes. (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/36676-courage-fukushima-50-true-heroes.html)

Ronin4hire 03-18-2011 06:06 AM

Courage of the Fukushima 50. True Heroes.
 
Quote:

The radiation levels at the plant entrance are at a level which will either kill the workers soon or cause them appalling illnesses in the years to come.
Experts have said that the airtight suits they are wearing would do little to stop the contamination.

The group remained behind after 700 of their colleagues fled when radiation levels became too dangerous.

Their identities have not been revealed, but experts said they are likely to be working class front-line technicians and firemen who know the plant the best.

It is thought that mostly older men have volunteered because they have already had children – younger workers might be rendered infertile by the high radiation doses.

Whilst the men are called the Fukushima Fifty, the group is thought to actually be 200-strong. They are doing four shifts in rotation, working on restarting the cooling systems.

Their heart-rending messages home were made public yesterday by Japanese national television, which has interviewed their relatives.

One relative said: 'My father is still working at the plant. He says he's accepted his fate, much like a death sentence.'

A woman said her husband who was at the plant had continued to work while fully aware he was being bombarded with radiation.

Another said that her 59-year-old father had volunteered for Fukushima duty, adding: 'I heard that he volunteered even though he will be retiring in just half a year and my eyes are filling up with tears.

'At home, he doesn't seem like someone who could handle big jobs. But today, I was really proud of him. I pray for his safe return.'
If Japan staves off Nuclear disaster. They owe it to these guys.

Japan tsunami: Fukushima Fifty 'on suicide mission' to battle nuclear meltdown | Mail Online

dogsbody70 03-18-2011 11:02 AM

you are so right ronin.totally selfless. surely this is a real warning to the rest of the world about the dangers of nuclear energy.




why is food not getting through to so many. i see reporters in refuge centres saying that food is running out yet the reporters get there.

surely there should be ways todistribute urgent items especially water.

ryuurui 03-18-2011 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dogsbody70 (Post 857528)
you are so right ronin.totally selfless. surely this is a real warning to the rest of the world about the dangers of nuclear energy.




why is food not getting through to so many. i see reporters in refuge centres saying that food is running out yet the reporters get there.

surely there should be ways todistribute urgent items especially water.

there are 2200 refugee centers on 500km radius area, and there are 3ook of them. that is why help is slow. lack of fule doesnt help either.

As to the workers at the plant. As much as I appreciate what they are doing I must say that they would not have had to do it if it was not for retarded superiors, TEPCO and other ^$%&$%£ that, as usual, messed up big time. On the other hand, when i was leaving Chiba on Tuesday there were people in my company ging to work desipite the approaching cloud (it was when winds have shifted south for 15h or so). For me, its a retarded behaviour and has much to to with mindless dedication to duty.
In case of the plant workers it's different. Those guys are heroes (yet at the same time victims of stupidity and recklessness of other people). Sadly, i doubt any lesson will be learned, and this disaster will only shorten upcoming economical fall of Japan.

termogard 03-18-2011 11:12 AM

Best of Japanese.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857471)
If Japan staves off Nuclear disaster. They owe it to these guys.

Japan tsunami: Fukushima Fifty 'on suicide mission' to battle nuclear meltdown | Mail Online

If mentioned article based on information of Japanese TV........

Real Heroes. I simply cannot find words to express feelings.... God bless THEM !

SgtBeavis 03-18-2011 01:29 PM

They are giants among mere men.

CarlVercetti 03-18-2011 02:00 PM

These men are really heroes. I sadly laugh when I think that there are true heroes, like these workers, and there are true evils, like Gheddafi in Libia that kill his nation...

termogard 03-18-2011 02:29 PM

Gododaff
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlVercetti (Post 857559)
These men are really heroes. I sadly laugh when I think that there are true heroes, like these workers, and there are true evils, like Gheddafi in Libia that kill his nation...

What current Libyan internal affairs, various Geddafs-Kaddafs have to do with desperate and heroic attempts of brave Japanese workers and technicians to hold a situation at Fukushima Dai-ichi NPP under control? Please, don't put various trash from euronews into this particular thread.

Eiffel 03-18-2011 03:22 PM

I don't know what to say, thanks a lot and god bless them !

GoNative 03-18-2011 04:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryuurui (Post 857529)
there are 2200 refugee centers on 500km radius area, and there are 3ook of them. that is why help is slow. lack of fule doesnt help either.

As to the workers at the plant. As much as I appreciate what they are doing I must say that they would not have had to do it if it was not for retarded superiors, TEPCO and other ^$%&$%£ that, as usual, messed up big time. On the other hand, when i was leaving Chiba on Tuesday there were people in my company ging to work desipite the approaching cloud (it was when winds have shifted south for 15h or so). For me, its a retarded behaviour and has much to to with mindless dedication to duty.
In case of the plant workers it's different. Those guys are heroes (yet at the same time victims of stupidity and recklessness of other people). Sadly, i doubt any lesson will be learned, and this disaster will only shorten upcoming economical fall of Japan.

They are not victims of stupidity at all. They are heroes in the true sense. People who are prepared to put themselves in potentially life threatening situations to save the lives of others. With full knowledge of the risks they have taken on the responsibility to avert a bigger disaster than has already happened. Nothing can be said that could lessen the sacrifice they are making and it would be inappropriate to suggest otherwise.

Please explain exactly how you believe TEPCO have messed up big time. I personally believe they have done well thus far considering the circumstances. This was a totally unprecendented event. The company in charge I think has little if anything to do with the current situation. All systems worked as they were supposed to except for an unprecented earthquake and tsunami which messed things up big time. I don't think blame can be layed purely on the company and I certainly don't think it will. Thankfully Japan doesn't play the blame games that happen so often in the west.

evanny 03-18-2011 05:49 PM

if Japan had military they could do what russians did.
2 minutes on the roof of Chernobyl and you get 2 years off from army. had no shortage of volunteers.

i just looked up the article i had about Chernobyl. a survivor who was telling how graphite that could be put out by water was thrown away by hands. water only went for the core.

looks like history is bound to repeat itself. Good luck guys, save everyone's Japan so i am not going to spend 3 years of learning japanese for nothing. :cool:

kouichisan 03-18-2011 06:46 PM

No matter what happens, they will be remembered forever.

I hope everything does go as planned.

BBC Published something similar.

BBC News - Japan hails the heroic 'Fukushima 50'

tokusatsufan 03-18-2011 07:20 PM

Ganbare,Fukushima 50. They really are saving the world.

JustinRossTso 03-18-2011 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by evanny (Post 857605)
looks like history is bound to repeat itself. Good luck guys, save everyone's Japan so i am not going to spend 3 years of learning japanese for nothing. :cool:

I don't believe it will happen again. You'll learn Japanese for something ;D! I don't think it's the end of the world yet. It's too early for 2012 even for Japan.

I have faith that the Japanese people will pull through, even in hard times. It's just the way they work!

Anyways... I almost cried when I read this. I really can't imagine myself doing this, I really admire them. Even more so than the "Tank" man.

termogard 03-18-2011 10:55 PM

military
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by evanny (Post 857605)
if Japan had military they could do what russians did.

Actually, Japan has well-developed armed forces called SDF.

JohnBraden 03-18-2011 11:31 PM

If they build a shrine to honor them, I will go and pay my respects.... Nothing short of altruism for these fine gentlemen....

Ronin4hire 03-19-2011 02:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoNative (Post 857592)
They are not victims of stupidity at all. They are heroes in the true sense. People who are prepared to put themselves in potentially life threatening situations to save the lives of others. With full knowledge of the risks they have taken on the responsibility to avert a bigger disaster than has already happened. Nothing can be said that could lessen the sacrifice they are making and it would be inappropriate to suggest otherwise.

Please explain exactly how you believe TEPCO have messed up big time. I personally believe they have done well thus far considering the circumstances. This was a totally unprecendented event. The company in charge I think has little if anything to do with the current situation. All systems worked as they were supposed to except for an unprecented earthquake and tsunami which messed things up big time. I don't think blame can be layed purely on the company and I certainly don't think it will. Thankfully Japan doesn't play the blame games that happen so often in the west.

It might be that they are both. Heroes AND victims of stupidity.

Wikileaks revealed a cable in which the Americans warned the Japanese that there were serious concerns about the ability of the Fukushima plant to survive the a serious quake. This cable has come to light since this disaster.

(On another point.. remember all the people complaining about Wikileaks and the mundane information it released? turns out some of it might not be so mundane after all. The original uprising in Tunisia is said to be caused partly by Wikileaks revelations... but anyway I digress.)

I know nothing of this TEPCO company... but if the concerns warranted by the USA were valid.. then some people have a lot of explaining to do.

GoNative 03-19-2011 03:11 AM

Got any link to the exact wording of this supposed warning? I've kind of lost trust in anything being reported by western media recently.

termogard 03-19-2011 03:27 AM

warning
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857662)
Wikileaks revealed a cable in which the Americans warned the Japanese that there were serious concerns about the ability of the Fukushima plant to survive the a serious quake.

Excellent. I am almost speechless. The reactors of Fukushima Dai-ichi were mostly designed by US engineers of General Electric.
So what did Americans want to hear from japanese side by sending that "warning"? Perhaps, japanese should close and scrap Fukushima Dai-ichi NPP prior to any earthquake ASAP?

RickOShay 03-19-2011 03:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryuurui (Post 857529)
there are 2200 refugee centers on 500km radius area, and there are 3ook of them. that is why help is slow. lack of fule doesnt help either.

As to the workers at the plant. As much as I appreciate what they are doing I must say that they would not have had to do it if it was not for retarded superiors, TEPCO and other ^$%&$%£ that, as usual, messed up big time. On the other hand, when i was leaving Chiba on Tuesday there were people in my company ging to work desipite the approaching cloud (it was when winds have shifted south for 15h or so). For me, its a retarded behaviour and has much to to with mindless dedication to duty.
In case of the plant workers it's different. Those guys are heroes (yet at the same time victims of stupidity and recklessness of other people). Sadly, i doubt any lesson will be learned, and this disaster will only shorten upcoming economical fall of Japan.

I understand from a psychological standpoint how you might be afraid. But the fact is scientifically speaking, people in Chiba, Tokyo etc have nothing to fear from radiation at this point. My decision not to freak out like some people and stay in Japan, is based on the exact opposite of any sort of mindlessness. To me the real mindlessness going on is the number of people who have really bought into the media's shameless fearmongering. All the media has done is taken focus away from Japan's bigger problem (at this point).. hundreds of thousands of homeless, cold, hungry people.

termogard 03-19-2011 03:43 AM

reactors
 
2 Attachment(s)
Despite various mechanisms of explosions in Chernobyl Nuclear Power Station (upper photo) and in Fukushima Dai-ichi NPP (below), after explosions damaged reactors looks out quite similar, constantly releasing radioactive vapor in atmosphere.

Ronin4hire 03-19-2011 03:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoNative (Post 857669)
Got any link to the exact wording of this supposed warning? I've kind of lost trust in anything being reported by western media recently.

Japan syndrome shows why we need WikiLeaks | The Australian

Not an exact wording though.

Quote:

IN December 2008, an official from the International Atomic Energy Agency pointed to "a serious problem" with nuclear reactors in areas of Japan prone to earthquakes.

Recent earthquakes "have exceeded the design basis for some nuclear plants", he told a meeting of the Nuclear Safety and Security Group of the Group of Eight countries. Moreover, safety guides for seismic activity had been revised only three times in the past 35 years, he added.

The information was recorded in a US diplomatic cable and comes to us courtesy of WikiLeaks. So do other cables, including one two years ago in which American officials described Tomihiro Taniguchi, a senior IAEA nuclear safety official and former head of the Japanese agency responsible for nuclear plant security following earthquakes, as "a weak manager and advocate, particularly with respect to confronting Japan's own safety practices". A few months earlier, Japanese MP Taro Kono told US diplomats the government was covering up nuclear accidents and obscuring the true costs and problems associated with the nuclear industry. The following year, the government reversed a court ruling that a nuclear plant in western Japan had to be closed because it could withstand an earthquake of only 6.5 magnitude.

evanny 03-19-2011 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by termogard (Post 857633)
Actually, Japan has well-developed armed forces called SDF.

it is not about well developed. it is about mandatory. since CCCR army was mandatory and rather horrible place to be people chose to spend 2 minutes next to nuclear reactor core on a meltdown instead of serving 2 years.

tokusatsufan 03-19-2011 10:07 AM

So have they saved the plant?

GoNative 03-19-2011 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857680)

Considering that the reactors actually survived the earthquake mostly intact I can't really see the validity of this little leak. Doubt they warned of a 10m tsunami ;)

termogard 03-19-2011 11:10 AM

mandatory
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by evanny (Post 857756)
it is not about well developed. it is about mandatory. since CCCR army was mandatory and rather horrible place to be people chose to spend 2 minutes next to nuclear reactor core on a meltdown instead of serving 2 years.

Yes, they chose rooftop of the edge of meltdown instead of two years of service.
Check this video more attentively, please. They had even less time than two minutes and moved enough fast in suits armoured by lead shields.

Ronin4hire 03-19-2011 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoNative (Post 857763)
Considering that the reactors actually survived the earthquake mostly intact I can't really see the validity of this little leak. Doubt they warned of a 10m tsunami ;)

Eh? The two are related obviously.

JohnBraden 03-19-2011 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857803)
Eh? The two are related obviously.

In this case, yes, they are. But I don't recall a tsunami warning in the Great Hanshin earthquake. I've gone through numerous earthquakes in the Tohoku region and most had no tsunami warning and those that did were less than 50cm....

This one was the equivalent of The Perfect Storm....

Ronin4hire 03-19-2011 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnBraden (Post 857806)
In this case, yes, they are. But I don't recall a tsunami warning in the Great Hanshin earthquake. I've gone through numerous earthquakes in the Tohoku region and most had no tsunami warning and those that did were less than 50cm....

This one was the equivalent of The Perfect Storm....

Earthquake with an epicenter in the ocean is almost always going to be followed by a tsunami warning dude.

GoNative 03-19-2011 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857803)
Eh? The two are related obviously.

No they are not obviously related at all. Not all earthquakes here are just off the coast and cause massive tsunamis that wipe out whole towns. Can you actually recall the last time that occurred in Japan? Most earthquakes here don't do that at all. Many occur inland with no effect on the ocean or sea at all. Many that occur out in the ocean also do not cause tsunamis. Was there a massive tsunami in the Christchurch earthquake? So a report from years ago about Japan reactors and their ability to withstand a high magnitude earthquake may not have made any mention at all of the potential risks of tsunamis. The reactors themselves operated exactly as designed and withstood the earthquake. An earthquake far greater than I believe the warning was about. So Japan just proved that these reactors can actually survive earthquakes of far greater magnitude than they were designed for. That's good news and a testament to their construction. The design didn't take into account a wave of that height though and that is something that I doubt any reactor in the world regardless of if they are near major earthquake zones or not would have design features to withstand.
So I disagree with the assertions of The Australian (as I usually do, it being a mouthpiece for the right side of politics in Australia ;) ).

Ronin4hire 03-19-2011 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoNative (Post 857839)
So a report from years ago about Japan reactors and their ability to withstand a high magnitude earthquake may not have made any mention at all of the potential risks of tsunamis.

Or it may have. Which is quite conceivable since the 2 phenomena are related.

Furthermore inland EQs don't usually have tsunami warnings.

Not to mention that the tsunami in SE Asia was caused by an EQ. That wasn't too long ago.

MarioMario 03-19-2011 06:57 PM

I admire people who know that nothing good they will not wait, but they also know their duty to their country. Real heroes.
And as we have in Russia? Our people say in such cases: "Everything will be fine, no danger"- and with these words are sent to certain death ...

Mel10 03-19-2011 07:27 PM

We are have the following message in our media:

"19.03.2011, 06:25 pm, german local time: After estimate of the IAEA is the entrance of the worst case for every day longer always unlikely"

If this are right that would be epic! =)

The 50 heros are the best!!!!

termogard 03-19-2011 07:45 PM

our people
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarioMario (Post 857859)
And as we have in Russia? Our people say in such cases: "Everything will be fine, no danger"- and with these words are sent to certain death ...

What are you talking about?

Ryzorian 03-20-2011 03:56 AM

I think they are actually 180 total they go in 50 man shifts. Yes they are herioc in their efforts knowing what is probable. Kinda like the 300 Spartans in a way.

termogard 03-20-2011 04:33 AM

Spartans
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryzorian (Post 857938)
I think they are actually 180 total they go in 50 man shifts. Yes they are herioc in their efforts knowing what is probable. Kinda like the 300 Spartans in a way.

Soviet authorities in Chernobyl made a rotation of rescuers. I posted a link to british documentary where a group of volunteers was shown. Robots did not work any long time at rooftor of damaged reactor because their electronic blocks of remote control failed due to very high level of ionizing radiation. So authorities picked up humans. Each volunteer wore gas mask, rubber suit with protective shields made of lead. They had a minute to get rooftop from a nearby service compartment, grab radioactive pieces of fuel or graphite, drop them into broken reactor and run away...After them, fresh group run onto rooftop....

Are those guys at Fukushima have a similar sort of rotation scheme, I wonder?

Ronin4hire 03-20-2011 04:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by termogard (Post 857961)

Are those guys at Fukushima have a similar sort of rotation scheme, I wonder?

Yes.

They rotate in groups of four if I remember correctly.

termogard 03-20-2011 04:41 AM

rotation
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857962)
Yes.

They rotate in groups of four if I remember correctly.

Thank you for info, Ronin !:vsign:

Ronin4hire 03-20-2011 04:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by termogard (Post 857967)
Thank you for info, Ronin !:vsign:

No problemo :vsign:

GoNative 03-20-2011 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin4hire (Post 857846)
Or it may have. Which is quite conceivable since the 2 phenomena are related.

Furthermore inland EQs don't usually have tsunami warnings.

Not to mention that the tsunami in SE Asia was caused by an EQ. That wasn't too long ago.

I think the point you are missing is that this quake was far larger than even any they were possibly warning about. It was the largest earthquake in recorded history in Japan. And still the reactors survived the quake. Amazing really. I don't think you would find any structure in the world is built to withstand a quake larger than anything ever recorded in the history of that country. This was totally unprecedented. Many areas along that coast have had previous tsunamis and had built large walls to prevent one entering their towns. These were specifically built to save lives and were not part of some bungling corporation trying to save money. They built walls to withstand the largest waves they ever expected. Problem was that no one ever expected a wave of this size. And that means no one. Not the Americans or anyone else. At least the Americans can rest easier now knowing that the reactors can obviously handle the larger sized quakes that they warned about. No problems there.

Ronin4hire 03-20-2011 08:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoNative (Post 857977)
I think the point you are missing is that this quake was far larger than even any they were possibly warning about. It was the largest earthquake in recorded history in Japan. And still the reactors survived the quake. Amazing really. I don't think you would find any structure in the world is built to withstand a quake larger than anything ever recorded in the history of that country. This was totally unprecedented. Many areas along that coast have had previous tsunamis and had built large walls to prevent one entering their towns. These were specifically built to save lives and were not part of some bungling corporation trying to save money. They built walls to withstand the largest waves they ever expected. Problem was that no one ever expected a wave of this size. And that means no one. Not the Americans or anyone else. At least the Americans can rest easier now knowing that the reactors can obviously handle the larger sized quakes that they warned about. No problems there.

Not really. It was the most powerful quake in Japan's history but it's epicentre was miles off the coast of Japan. While it was a magnitude 9 quake, the actual force in many centres of Japan were about half that of the quake in Christchurch. (Christchurch was said to be 2.2G's of force while the recorded G's in Tokyo were said to be 0.82 if I remember correctly.)

All the damage in Japan was done by tsunami, very little was caused by the quake itself.

Furthermore, while the backup generators of the Fukushima plant were taken out by the tsunami, it was the initial quake that stopped the cooling system altogether.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:57 PM.

SEO by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6