JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   Japanese Language Help (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-language-help/)
-   -   I have some small questions about grammer (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-language-help/38900-i-have-some-small-questions-about-grammer.html)

KurumuHatake 08-12-2011 09:31 PM

I have some small questions about grammer
 
Hello :ywave:, and Thanks for looking. I'm a beginner in Japanese, and would really appreciate if you could answer a few, if not all, of my questions. They all have to do, I think, with grammar.

1) "where is my ___?"

I say, "私「わたし」の猫「ねこ」がどこにいますか?" (Where is my cat?)
But is this proper? Should が come after に?

2) "My cat is on top of the tree" or "There is a cat on top of the tree"

I say, "木「き」のうえに私の猫がいます。" (My Cat is on top of tree)
or I say, "木のうえに猫がいます。" (There is a cat on top of the tree)
Is there anything wrong with either of the two sentences?

3) can 何「なん or なに」 be used by it's self. You know, just as "What?" or do I have to add か at the end?
I thought I heard it one time when I was watching an anime with English subtitles. I've been curious ever since.

4) when referring to my eye should I use います or あります?

どおもありがとう。:vsign:

MMM 08-12-2011 09:44 PM

1) が never comes right after に.

2) I think they both are fine. I would probably say

私の猫が木の上にいます。

3) Yes, なに can be used by itself, but it is quite direct and literally means "What?" as in "What did you just say?"

何か means "something" (just as どこか means "somewhere", etc.)

何か by itself would only be used to say "[Is there a problem with] something?" and should probably be avoided.

In polite speech, say 何ですか.

phoenixheart 08-12-2011 11:47 PM

I know someone already answered, but the more the better, right?

Essentially:

1. Word order doesn't matter here. Just a preference thing, in my experience.

2. Depends on which one you want to emphasize, where your cat is or fact that there's a tree with a cat in it.

3. 何 can be used by itself. The ways I've heard it--in anime and in real life--are:

何が? [what is it? (subject)]

何ですか? [what is it? (nominative)]

何(なに)?[what?]

It can only be in a question sentence, because simply the fact that the word "what" appears in the sentence makes the sentence a question. This is true in all languages.

4. Referring to your eye would be あります。
私は目が二つあります。 (I have two eyes).

Hope this helps!

KurumuHatake 08-13-2011 01:10 AM

Thank You Both for your Kindness, and your answers. They both helped a lot. :)

masaegu 08-13-2011 02:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KurumuHatake (Post 875806)
I say, "私「わたし」の猫「ねこ」がどこにいますか?" (Where is my cat?)
But is this proper? Should が come after に?

I am surprised that no one has corrected this yet, but you NEVER use 「が」in asking "Where is ~~?". Do use「は」.

Quote:

3) can 何「なん or なに」 be used by it's self. You know, just as "What?" or do I have to add か at the end?
I thought I heard it one time when I was watching an anime with English subtitles. I've been curious ever since.
When used by itself, the pronunciation is always 「なに」.

「なにか?」 means "Do you want to say something?", "Is something wrong?", etc.

Quote:

どおもありがとう。:vsign:
The word is written 「どうも」 even though it is pronounced like 「どおも」.

KurumuHatake 08-13-2011 03:28 AM

@Masaegu Thank you vary much.

Quote:

I am surprised that no one has corrected this yet, but you NEVER use 「が」in asking "Where is ~~?". Do use「は」.
It's good you told me this, so I don't sound funny speaking to someone someday. :)

Quote:

The word is written 「どうも」 even though it is pronounced like 「どおも」.
oops. Thank you vary much. I'll remember that.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:24 AM.

SEO by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6