JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   Site Suggestions (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/site-suggestions/)
-   -   Members List is huge. (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/site-suggestions/12792-members-list-huge.html)

Odin 02-24-2008 04:00 AM

Members List is huge.
 
I new to Japan Forum, so I've been looking though the Members List. I couldn't help but notice the massive amount of accounts that have never posted. Perhaps there needs to be a pruning of unused accounts.


for example:
If the account is over six months old, and has never had a single post it should be deleted.
Before deletion, maybe a email, could be sent as a warning.
Do not delete if the user has posted before.

Lucyenn 02-27-2008 06:14 AM

_.-
 
Of course there are 60% that register and never posts, should be deleted!

anrakushi 02-27-2008 06:49 AM

there are plenty of things that possibly could be done around here but haven't been. just have to live with it i guess :)

Lucyenn 03-01-2008 06:16 PM

yeah som should be deleted!

persiandragon 03-05-2008 01:51 AM

some people could be active by reading posts, so saying that they should be deleted if they haven't posted anything i think is not really a good way.

phishn37 03-05-2008 03:27 AM

I guess you could cut down on the members list if it really bugged some people, but does it make any difference in the actual forum ~ ?

Eiri 03-10-2008 08:57 PM

well I think its a good idea I mean why have a huge ass list that has a shit load of members that are new, have no posts and dont even visit the site....plus it'll be easier when ppl randomly want to go thru the members list, since the list will be shorter and easier to find some1 instead of having to skip thru so many names...

Crani 05-18-2008 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by persiandragon (Post 418666)
some people could be active by reading posts, so saying that they should be deleted if they haven't posted anything i think is not really a good way.

Well, how about deleting the accounts with zero post and haven't logged in the forum for six months? Two birds with one stone.

Petahpie 05-20-2008 09:00 AM

@persiandragon: if you sent an email as a warning first it would solve that problem.


@crani: without the "w" in two, it makes me think of an army marching towards a flock of birds on a rock. "ONWARD! To birds with one stone!"
:vsign:
just letting you know, because I've NEVER made a typo. Ever.
*is lying*

KikiBunny23 05-20-2008 12:01 PM

this is a good idea but if people sent an email....yes i know, its the proper thing to do..but my point is. if you sent an email to the inactive people then the just might come here for a day, make a post or two then do the whole thing again 6months from now just to save their account.

TalnSG 05-20-2008 01:49 PM

Though I post regularly, I see value in those who only read the forum. Other than the General Topics, there is much to be learned hear from by those who are busier "listening" than "talking".

I say test the email addresses of those who are inactive and then delete those that are no longer valid. Any pruning of the membership beyond this is a disservice to many of the actual Japan-focused threads.

Besides the volume of the member list should only be an issue of capacity. Any system handling this volume of posting should not be looking to it membership data to free up capacity. Compared to storing the posts it's storage requirement is miniscule. The only others who I can see needing the membership list compacted would be either spammers or stalkers collecting data. Why would anyone else mind scanning more than a screen or two to find someone's profile that they wanted to contact?

forgotenmemory 05-20-2008 11:48 PM

Delete that ones that haven't been on since they registered? lol

MissMisa 05-21-2008 06:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TalnSG (Post 493506)
Though I post regularly, I see value in those who only read the forum. Other than the General Topics, there is much to be learned hear from by those who are busier "listening" than "talking".

I say test the email addresses of those who are inactive and then delete those that are no longer valid. Any pruning of the membership beyond this is a disservice to many of the actual Japan-focused threads.

Besides the volume of the member list should only be an issue of capacity. Any system handling this volume of posting should not be looking to it membership data to free up capacity. Compared to storing the posts it's storage requirement is miniscule. The only others who I can see needing the membership list compacted would be either spammers or stalkers collecting data. Why would anyone else mind scanning more than a screen or two to find someone's profile that they wanted to contact?

If they only read the forum, then there would be no need to actually have an account. And if there were parts of the forum you couldn't see without an account, they would probably have signed in a few intervals to have a look, and you can tell this by the 'Last Activity' part in their profile.

The member list is massive and full of people who never posted on the site after registering, or only posted one thread and never came back to check the replied [which I think is this most annoying thing to do.]

However, it begs the question, what's the point in the clean up? Maybe it should just be to give an accurate measure of how many members are actually active on JapanForum, I don't know. But looking at that list it is absolutely massive and it seems we only have a few active mods, I doubt they want to waste their time doing all that. And the main admin of this site isn't here anymore I don't think, I presume it's that ShinjukuEki because they have the ability to post on the main page? Though you can't tell whether that person is active or not ^-^;;

TalnSG 05-21-2008 02:01 PM

Back to my main point..... why does it matter to anyone what the size of the member list is?

Are any of you security or system administrators? Editing a user list is frigging busy work that no one wants to do unless there is a problem.

MyvPops818 05-29-2008 01:20 AM

I agree. If there isn't a problem, why do anything?


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:01 PM.

SEO by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6