The Joker Vs. Tony Montana

[rison]

Originally Posted by Compaqmac321

i just figured out wat IMO means
lol

@sephiroth
then what movie do you feel had a character that was played the best no the best movie, but an actor who played a character flawlessly

Nicole Kidman in "The Hours"
Robert Di niro in "Casino"
They actually played their parts well without hype, read the reviews.

I never like any Superman just for the reasons you made.

[Compaqmac321]

ive seen those movies, they werent amazing to me

to me denzel washington as malcom x and the hurricane were official too.

have you ever seen any of the supermans with christopher reeves?

[Salvanas]

On topic wise, out of both Al Pacino wins hands down.

Don't get me wrong, Heath was amazing as the Joker. Spectacular. However, Al Pacino never fails to impress with his acting. Simply amazing.

[MMM]

Originally Posted by Reavyn

There are quite a few people who think this. I can't say I disagree. He did a phenomenal job as the joker and I still like it better than scarface. But I think the movie got way more attention than it would have because of his untimely demise.

Getting more attention because of a lead actor's death and being overrated are two different things.

[Compaqmac321]

Originally Posted by MMM

Getting more attention because of a lead actor's death and being overrated are two different things.

exactly, heath dying might sell tickets, but im not talking about sales or even the movie itself
hes had another movie after batman that ppl rarely even mention (it comes out this year)
but ppl mention batman and the joker cus his acting was legit, and that was way before he died

[rison]

Originally Posted by Compaqmac321

ive seen those movies, they werent amazing to me

to me denzel washington as malcom x and the hurricane were official too.

have you ever seen any of the supermans with christopher reeves?

You asked for films were characters were played flawlessly and I listed some, the films dont have to made great impression.

those movies you listed also are right but in Training Day, the acting was almost flawless.

i have but Batman movies have always been better organised story-line terms.

[Compaqmac321]

training day too, i just thought that alot of ppl didnt see it so i didnt mention it
and what i meant was they werent played that flawlessly to me
even tho the hours got oscar nods and won

[rison]

Originally Posted by Compaqmac321

training day too, i just thought that alot of ppl didnt see it so i didnt mention it
and what i meant was they werent played that flawlessly to me
even tho the hours got oscar nods and won

I think you are missing the point here, the characters is what is being discussed here not the film as a whole, right? Heath Ledger might play Joker well while the film is overrated.

[Compaqmac321]

Originally Posted by rison

I think you are missing the point here, the characters is what is being discussed here not the film as a whole, right? Heath Ledger might play Joker well while the film is overrated.

im not missing the point, i made the thread
and NICOLE KIDMAN got the oscar for her role in the hours so im not talking about the movie.
the only time i mentioned something about movies itself was when some1 said they thought both movies were overrated, and i made a side comment on that

its always been about the characters, like i stated from the start

[SephirothVVC]

Originally Posted by Compaqmac321

im not missing the point, i made the thread
and NICOLE KIDMAN got the oscar for her role in the hours so im not talking about the movie.
the only time i mentioned something about movies itself was when some1 said they thought both movies were overrated, and i made a side comment on that

its always been about the characters, like i stated from the start

o sorry i thought it was about the movie and the actors