|
|||
12-24-2009, 08:49 AM
sorry cris
you can usually get free papers and crappy magazines full of adverts at a japanese food shop. also most publishing houses will do international subscriptions, i know IPC, NATmags FT etc. do and you can probably get special offers if you look |
|
||||
12-24-2009, 11:02 AM
I'm all for self-study learning and trying to get by without too many explanations etc.
But honestly, if you try learning from newspapers etc from being a beginner, it will in most cases either: A: Make you hate the language B: Take an extremely long time to learn the basics C: Get you speaking broken Japanese because of crappy assumptions you made when starting out At least read Tae Kim's site. Also when you can afford it, get a grammar dictionary. Like this: Amazon.com: A Dictionary of Basic Japanese Grammar (9784789004541): Seiichi Makino, Michio Tsutsui: Books Other than that, Japanese google is your friend, if you really want native material, search for it in Japanese and find something you like: (I'm assuming you can do this since you are confident you can learn from newspapers etc) |
|
||||
12-24-2009, 03:03 PM
Quote:
You don't learn to read Japanese through picking up a newspaper. Were it that easy, anyone could do it. No, I didn't have a book called 'Learn English in 3 steps' as a child. I had a whole community of native English speakers who taught it to me. I was surrounded by English on a constant basis. I didn't pick up a book in English and start reading it from the get go. You may not have even looked at the resources people have linked you, because there are Japanese-only textbooks and sites out there. Hiragana Times, which Hatred linked, is a prime example. A newspaper is not immersion. If you want immersion, you'll have to surround yourself with Japanese; meaning live / study in Japan. Edit: Browsing through the sites I linked more thoroughly, there are Japanese books / magazines and manga available, and by 'Japanese books' I mean books in Japanese, not the learning materials you are so adamantly against. And if the Hiragana Times are too easy for you, you could always try other Japanese newspapers like The Daily Yomiuri. |
|
||||
12-24-2009, 03:14 PM
On the contrary it is you that has not thought this through.
You've been nothing but rude to people who have tried to help through this whole thread. To be honest I'm surprised anyone helped you at all (Including myself) Your right, you can learn through immersion only, and immersion is a great way to learn and pick new things up, but textbooks and dictionaries etc where created to give learners a kind of short cut. I don't like textbooks and things like that myself, but to rule them out entirely is in my opinion shooting yourself in the foot. The only books I use are grammar dictionaries (Since I hate textbooks so much) No matter what you think it would probably be worthwhile investing in one. But I guess if you want to shoot yourself in the foot... 十人十色 right? Use Google. That's all you will ever need. Here is a search hint: Amazon Since you are unwilling to accept any ones answers I'm surprised you came here at all. Come back and show us your amazing Japanese... whenever that is. Without using any form of English help it's going to be years. |
|
||||
12-24-2009, 07:39 PM
Hatredcopter is right. A Japanese newspaper is useless in learning fundamental Japanese.
If you want to see Japanese in context, then the Internet is much cheaper and more accessible. There are even plug-ins in Firefox that show you the readings and meaning of kanji. I would recommend being a little more appreciative of the answers people are giving you, or next time there may not be any. |
|
||||
12-24-2009, 08:19 PM
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I don't know if its an issue of pride, or if its an issue of just 'wanting to have Japanese stuff', but if you're actually sincere about learning Japanese, you'll find a class, tutor, textbook, or something. Materials like magazines and newspapers can be used as a supplement to your learning - but you'll never learn a thing with them all by themselves. |
|
|||
12-24-2009, 08:41 PM
If it's possible to learn Japanese from scratch via newspapers (I totally doubt it), you'll have a very poor background on Japanese colloquialism. You'll be better off reading Japanese scholarly papers or go to an academic conference... instead of reading manga and novels, watching TV shows, or use Japanese in daily life situations.
|
Thread Tools | |
|
|