X Japan reforms in December!!!!!!!!!

[XjapanFOREVER]

Originally Posted by Touya

But the reform isn't making any new music. They're honoring the old stuff. Yoshiki has an army of guitarist to play hide's part. An army of people to replace one man. And the reform isn't permanent. Yoshiki said it was just a form of closing. Closing doesn't mean better or more. It means letting go. We have the memories; live for today.

Not true! YOSHIKI has never stated that they wouldn't make new music! In fact, the only official thing about the reformation is the release of a NEW single by them, Without You.
Toshi has been quoted stating that he won't sing any "violent" songs, but would be more than happy to sing ballads... Maybe we'll see a new, strictly ballad version of X..

[Touya]

Without You is not new music. It's on four other albums. Pata and Heath haven't agreed to play yet so don't line your ducks up yet.

The only thing NEW about X reform is no hide. I can give you the interview where Yo-chan states he's using it as a closing to the past. That doesn't sound permanent at all.

I love Yo-chan and I hope he finds his closing he needs with this. Sad Yo-chan is not good...

[XjapanFOREVER]

But with Toshi singing it, it would be new music!
Pata and Heath have always been up for an X reunion, the only person who's been against it is Toshi, and he's finally agreed!

[Touya]

Do you want Toshi singing Without You that badly? I have it. I can certainly share it with you.

For being up to it why haven't they said yes yet then?

Yoshi has only been asking the last six months or so. I'll believe it'll happen when it happens.

[XjapanFOREVER]

you have it? It hasn't been recorded with Toshi singing it, officially?
They've always been up for it! On Yoshikinet.com it stated, back when Toshi first agreed, that the reason all other chances for an X reunion were scrapped was because Toshi would never agree to it.

but, by all means, please up the song!

[Touya]

>sigh< It's not really that good. And it's virtually the same as Longing. It is technically the same as Longing... If you have Eternal Melodies and The Last Live listen to Without You then listen to Longing... I think Yoshiki got lazy with the song writing....

[XjapanFOREVER]

hmph...
if you say so.

[Touya]

No joke. Yoshiki must have been tired or something.

And on a side note, I really don't want them to make any new songs. It's not for them. Just it would feel wrong if they did.

[XjapanFOREVER]

I don't think it would, it'd give me something new to listen to... XD

[Touya]

I have to find it. My library keeps throwing up Violet UK. >.<

Not that I don't like Violet UK but that's not what I'm looking for. I hope my sister didn't erase my X music again...